![]()
If a survey were taken of
all shortwave DXers to find the antennas they use, I suspect the
majority would be found using the random wire. Next In popularity
would likely be the commercially available sloper antennas and
trap dipole.
However, an antenna's popularity
does not necessarily reflect excellent performance. While being
simple and inexpensive to erect, the randomwire is susceptible
to electrical noise, and presents a wide range of impedance to
the receiver, depending on received frequency.
The terminated. tilted, folded
dipole (T2FD) is a little known antenna that performs excellently.
Compact in size compared to a halfwave dipole (approx. 67
feet long at 60 meters), the T2FD provides signal gain, wide frequency
coverage, and exceptionally low noise characteristics.
An early discussion of the
T2FD appeared in the June 1949 issue of QST, a popular magazine
for radio amateurs. The author of this article continued his examination
of the T2FD in the November 1951 QST as well as the February 1953
issue of the same magazine. A more recent article on the T2FD
appeared in the May 1984 73 Magazine.
The World Radio Television
Handbook for 1988 gave a brief description and diagram of the
T2FD, and that year's WRTH Newsletter provided additional construction
information. Further details were given in the 1989 WRTH. However,
some misleading and incomplete information is given in these WRTH
sources, which this article will later clarify.
DESIGN
Some have called the T2FD
a "squashed rhombic" antenna. It does bear some design
similarities to the nonresonant rhombic, but theoretically
it is admittedly inferior. However, the T2PD performs well in
a modest amount of space, while a rhombic antenna can be immense
virtually impractical at all but the highest SWBC
bands.
The T2FD is essentially a
closed loop design with the element ends folded back and joined
by a noninductive resistor (see figure below). The feed
line can be 300 to 600 ohm twinlead or open line.
Because twinlead and open
line can be affected by nearby metallic objets (downspouts, metal
window frames etc.), a better feed line is coaxia1 cable connected
to an impedance transformer (balun).
The T2FD has a characteristic
5 or 6 to l frequency ratio, which means that it works effectively
from its lowend design frequency up to 5 or 6 times that
frequency. For instance, the T2FD which I use is designed for
optimum performance at 4.9 MHz, but can operate up to the 2529
MHz range. In practice this antenna aIso works satisfactorily
down to the 75 90 meter tropical bands, but not as well
as a dipole or delta loop designed for 75 or 90 meters.
PERFORMANCE
The United States Navy conducted
extensive transmitting and receiving tests of a single T2FD antenna
in the late 1940s at Long Beach, California. They employed a Model
TCC Navy I kW transmitter, with a frequency range from 2.0 to
18.0 MHz. After a year of use on all frequencies the T2PD was
found to be superior to individual antennas on the various bands.
The other antennas were removed from the Long Beach site affair
the tests.
Similar results during the
same period were experienced by the Kyushu Electric Communications
Bureau of Japan. Their experiments indicated that the terminated
tilted folded dipole was superior to the "zepp'' and halfwave
dipole types previously used. They noted wideband characteristics,
and the T2PD gave a 4 to 8 dB signal increase at their various
receiver site
My experience has shown the
T2FD to be a fine performer when only a single shortwave receiving
antenna can be erected, due to its wideband nature. It also has
the advantage of electrical noise rejection (to a degree) compared
to a random wire or even a dipole.
THE TERMINATING RESISTOR
According to the QST articles
mentioned, the value of the terminating resistor is rather critical.
Its value depends on the feedpoint impedance, and is normally
above it. For instance, if 300 ohm feed line is used (or 75 ohm
coax into a 41 balun) the correct termination value is 390
ohms. For 600 ohm feed line, a 650 ohm value is best. If a 450
ohm feed line is in use, the correct resistor would be in the
vicinity of 500 ohms. I have not discovered why the optimum terminating
resistance is higher than the feedpoint impedance, nor do I know
of a formula for calculating this relationship.
The terminating resistance
becomes more critical as the feedpoint impedance is lowered. With
lines of lower impedance (including a directly connected 50 ohm
coaxial cable), the value is critical within about 5 ohms. (The
QST articles did not state an exact recommended value when using
a low impedance line.)
The WRTH editions give the erroneous impression that T2FD antennas require a 500 ohm resistor
and a 10:1 balun transformer, used with 50 ohm coax cable. This
is not the case, although these values will work fine if you have
the 10:1 balun available (normally hard to come by). A T2FD built
with 75 ohm coax (RG59 or RG6), a common 4:1
balun, and a 390 ohm terminating resistor is recommended.
The resistor used must not
be a wirewound type, its inductance would affect performance
to a substantial degree. A carbon
resistor of 1/2 to 1 watt in size is perfect (for a receive only
T2FD). The WRTH Newsletter in 1988 said that the wire for a T2FD
must be made of pure copper between 3mm and 5mm thick In reality,
the exact tbickness and type of wire have very little bearing
on the T2FDs performance for receiving. Your main consideration
will be wire strength, regardless of diameter.
CONSTRUCTION TIPS
A T2FD takes more hardware
to construct than a typical dipole. Maintaining a uniform spacing
between the parallel wires, as well as sturdiness, are the primary
considerations. My first attempt at a T2FD selfdestructed
when the antenna was hoisted into the air. I underestimated tbe
strain the wires would be under. My current T2FD has been in use
for over 11/2 years, and was built with 14 gauge stranded,
colddrawn copperwire.
The spacers or spreader bars
ean be fashioned from 5/8" (minimum) diameter wood dowels,
or even acrylic rod if available. Drill appropriate sized holes
at eacb end of the spreader bar for the wire to pass through.
The spreaders should be secured to the wires so that they do not
slide; one method is to "jumper" each spreader end with
a short piece of stiff wire and solder to the antenna wire.
It is essential that you encase
the terminating resistor inside a plastic cylinder or other support,
and weatherproof the assembly. Be positive that the resistor will
not receive the strain from the wires.
I prefer to use eyelet bolts
on the end spreader bars for tbe antenna wire to pass through.
An alternative would be some type of rod or strong, small diameter
tubing cut to the length of dimension "B". The wire
would simply thread through the rod.
Most amateur radio supply
stores sell 4:1 baluns tbat only need a wrap of "Coax Seal"
around the connections to be totally waterproof. The type with
a coax connector that will accept a PL259 plug is perfect.
The diagram on the following page illustrates this type of construction, using the commonly
available 4:1 balun, 390 ohm resistor, and 75 ohm RG59 coaxial
cable. © Copyright worldwide by Proceedings and author. |